Cottage vacation rentals in Fairfield County

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

Top-rated cottage rentals in Fairfield County

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A bright and airy Great Room is showcased, featuring a cozy seating area with a blue couch and a stylish armchair. Large windows frame lake views, while a gas fireplace adds warmth. A mounted television is positioned above a stone accent wall, complementing the overall décor.

Cottage in Buckeye

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 57 reviews

The Paddle Inn-Buckeye Lake cottage on the Water

Welcome to this lovely lake front cottage on the North Bank of Buckeye Lake! Beautiful views from the wall of windows in the spacious vaulted Great Room. This 1930's cottage has many recent updates & improvements including a loft with spiral stairs, gas fireplace, balcony overlook with spiral stairs for panoramic views of the lake. Rental docks nearby. Located within a short walking distance to local businesses. All Short Term rentals in Buckeye Lake are governed under Ord. #2022-36, 2023-27.

Guest favorite

A bright living room is showcased with natural light, featuring a gray sofa and armchair. A wooden coffee table is positioned in front of the sofa, accented by a small plant. French doors open to the entryway, framed with decorative wreaths.

Cottage in Buckeye Lake

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 128 reviews

Anchors Away - Relaxing Cottage Minutes from Lake

Newly remodeled home just a short walk to the Lake, Bars & Restaurants! 2 bedrooms & 2.5 bathrooms with a cozy nautical design. Fully stocked kitchen and spacious living room are perfect for vacationing with family! Additional amenities included for our guests are: 3 Bikes, Yard Games, Firepit, Propane Grill & Board Games We can accommodate a MAX of 3 Cars and no street parking available. All Short-Term Rentals in the Village of Buckeye Lake are governed under Ordinances #2022-36/#2023-27

Guest favorite

A charming cottage features a light blue exterior with three large windows allowing ample natural light. Two white chairs are positioned on the welcoming porch, and a decorative sign reading 'Paws and Relax' is displayed prominently above the entrance.

Cottage in Buckeye Lake

5 out of 5 average rating, 55 reviews

Location, location, location!!!

Welcome to our super cute, super clean cottage, located on the main lake, and directly on the bike path. Close proximity to the area's most popular dining options; the Boat Yard, the Buckeye Lake Yacht club, the Brewery, & Chef Shak, to name a few. Enjoy a scoop of ice cream and listen to the live music at Dips at the Lake. Bike & boat rental area within walking distance. 6 miles from Legend Valley. Parking is limited. (2 cars, max) There is a dock available, for an additional fee.

Guest favorite

A serene view of Buckeye Lake features lush green grass and a calm waterfront. A wooden dock extends into the water, flanked by trees. In the background, the cottage is visible, surrounded by greenery and distant buildings, under a clear blue sky.

Cottage in Millersport

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Cozy 2 Bedroom Buckeye Lake with Lakeview

Welcome to the Chelsea Cottage at buckeye Lake: the cleanest cottage with the most comfortable beds in the area and a view of the water from the front deck. Updated cottage with a gorgeous water view from the front deck! Brand new furnishings, comfortable beds and updates throughout. Enjoy the fire pit, coffee on the deck or go out and explore Buckeye Lake and the amazing surrounding area! Please note only two vehicles are allowed as that is all the room we have in the parking area!

Superhost

Two gray Adirondack chairs are positioned on a grassy outdoor area, facing each other. A light blue bucket filled with bottles sits between them, while additional chairs are visible in the background, framed by lush green trees.

Cottage in Thornville

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 66 reviews

Waterfront Cottage with Boat Dock at Buckeye Lake!

Soak up the lake atmosphere in this newly-rebuilt stone cottage w/private boat dock. Amenities nestled throughout bright finishes contrasting beautiful reclaimed wood. Private outdoor eating areas, hot tub, fenced yard & guest house w/ mini kitchenette. Inside, enjoy a full kitchen w/eating space, ice machine & comfy living and sleeping areas. Mins from Winery & Restaurants and just steps from Dockside Grill. 3 car free parking! Nov - Feb also avail monthly @ discount. Dogs welcome!

Guest favorite

The cottage is nestled among trees, with warm light glowing from its windows. The structure features a sloped roof and wooden deck, with greenery surrounding the area, providing a serene outdoor setting. The atmosphere suggests a peaceful retreat in a woodland environment.

Cottage in Millersport

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 41 reviews

Cozy Canal Cottage • Buckeye Lake

Welcome! 🌿 •Get away from the rush of life at this quaint, uniquely designed and tranquil cottage nestled along the Buckeye Lake canal. •This cottage offers 2 bedrooms and 2 baths, full kitchen, and a peaceful atmosphere. Don’t forget the plush robes to relax in. •You will be a short distance from Millersport Coffee, restaurants + breakfast, gift shops, and bike, boat + kayak rentals. Take a short drive to the lakeside breweries and more! The adventures are endless. Enjoy! 🛶 🎣

Guest favorite

Cottage in Thornville

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 128 reviews

Buckeye Lake Retreat

A great place for families and fishermen Beautiful home right on the channel and direct access to the lake. Excellent for fishing, catching catfish right from the dock. It's an excellent place to relax and unwind. Fish directly off the dock or use the Kayaks included to explore the lake. We have an extra-long dock that can accommodate your boat(s). Fully equipped kitchen, your own washer and dryer, and a gas grill. There is a fire pit for the nights you want a campfire.

Guest favorite

A light and airy dining area features a round table set for four, adorned with elegant glassware and a vase of fresh flowers. Comfortable seating is provided by stylish gray cushions along the wall, while natural light enters through a nearby window.

Cottage in Buckeye Lake

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 142 reviews

Newly renovated 2-bedroom cottage by the lake

This newly remodeled cottage is perfectly located on the north bank side of Buckeye Lake just blocks off the water. You will enjoy quick and easy access to all the amenities and lakeside fun you could ever want. *North Shore Ramp -3min/drive (put your boat in) *Buckeye Lake Brewery/Chef Shack-2min/walk *Boatyard-4min/walk Property is 2 full lots with 1 whole lot available for all your parking needs. Whether you bring your own boat or rent one, there is plenty of parking.

Guest favorite

An open-concept living space features a comfortable sofa, a modern kitchen area with a large island and two stools, and a welcoming front entrance. Light wood accents and soft blue walls create a calm atmosphere, enhanced by natural light from windows.

Cottage in Circleville

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

The Cottage @ Tarlton's Edge

Take a break and unwind at this cozy 2bd 1 bath cottage getaway with a hot tub! Bedroom with King bed and closet Bedroom with Queen bed Covered front porch with glider. Back patio with table, hot tub and gas grill. Nice sized back yard with dire pit (roasting sticks and bag chairs in shed) Full-size washer/dryer. Large island, open concept. comfy sofa, table w/benches. Smart tv, wifi. Lancaster or Chillicothe less than 30 min drive, Circleville less than 15mins

Superhost

Cottage in Buckeye Lake

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

The Blue Tin Lady Cottage, walk to the lake.

This Buckeye Lake Cottage getaway is located conveniently to the main entrance of the lake which is entertainment for boating, water and jet skiing, tubing, kayaking, and beach. Beautiful bike trails over 4 miles of wonderful views around the lake! Plenty of parking for cars, boats and trailers. Newly remodeled...everything is new, due to this we are not accepting pets. “All Short-Term Rentals in the Village of Buckeye Lake are governed under Ordinance #2024-22.

Guest favorite

A cozy living area is highlighted by warm wooden walls and a plush blue sofa. A round dining table surrounded by chairs invites gatherings. The space is illuminated by natural light filtering through large, covered windows, enhancing the warm ambiance.

Cottage in Lancaster

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 180 reviews

Cheerful 1-bedroom cottage with indoor fireplace

Welcome travelers to the Rockmill Cottage! This bright, one bedroom guesthouse is located across the street from the historic mill and a short drive to restaurants, grocers, shops, and breweries. Enjoy the craftsman woodwork throughout, including a gas fireplace, fully appointed kitchen and cozy loft. In warmer months, the outdoor gazebo is perfect for morning coffee or a picnic. Please note that the cottage is on the same property as the Rockmill Farmhouse.

Guest favorite

Cottage in Buckeye Lake

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 65 reviews

Cozy 4-bedroom cottage with lake view and patio

Welcome to Buckeye Lake! This cozy, coastal-themed four-bedroom cottage is perfect for a getaway with friends and family. With lake views from the kitchen and Master bedroom, you are sure to enjoy what the lake has to offer! Access to Crane and Buckeye Lake and kid-friendly beach. Perfect distance to walk or bike ride to local bars (The Boatyard and Buckeye Lake Brewery), ice cream, and the Buckeye Lake Yacht Club.